About Us
At First Baptist Church Brewster, we are guided by our faith in the teachings of Jesus Christ.
We believe in the power of prayer, the authority of the Bible, and the importance of vibrant worship. We are committed to serving our community and sharing the message of God's grace and forgiveness.
Our Mission
We glorify God and make disciples by touching the world with the redemptive love and message of Jesus Christ… everyone, everywhere, everyday.
Our Values
We are committed to living out the values of the gospel of Jesus Christ. Our mission is to love God, love others, and share the good news of Jesus Christ.Â
Desperate for Jesus
We urgently need Jesus for our life and identity. He is our great news and we can do nothing apart from Him. Our truest identity is who we are in Jesus, and we become like Jesus as we behold Jesus.
How desperately are you pursing and proclaiming Him today?
Verses: Psalm 63:1; John 15:5, Colossians 3:4, 4:2
No One Stands Alone
Investing in relationships to encourage one another to take our next step in following Jesus. Our lives are not meant to be lived alone.
Are you participating in a small group?
Verses: Hebrews 3:13, 10:24-25
Live to Give
Living lives of sacrifice to bring Heaven down here through our time, talents, and treasures.
What is it about your lifestyle that reflects a life of service?
Verses: Matthew 6:10; Mark 10:45; Romans 12:1
Grow to Go
Remaining teachable to become useable for God’s Kingdom
How is God growing you and who are you sharing that growth with?
Verses: Matthew 28:19-20; 2 Timothy 2:2, 2:21; James 4:6
All for One
Working together in unity with one another and the larger family of God that centers on Jesus and His mission
How are you nurturing unity within the local, regional, and global church?
Verses: John 17:20-23; Eph 4:3; Romans 15:5-6
Love On People
Letting the love of God flow to others through us.
Who is God asking you to love on today?
Verses: Matthew 22:37-40; 1 Thessalonians 3:12; 1 John 3:23
No Perfect People Allowed
No pretending that we have it all together – we are all on a journey with God
Are you being real and transparent to others about where you are at?
Verses: Matthew 11:28-30; Romans 15:7; Gal 6:2-3
Our Beliefs
We invite you to explore our beliefs and join us in our pursuit of living out our faith in boldness and passion.
The Word of God
God wrote the book so that makes it inspired and authoritative. The Bible is also the most trustworthy, historical and reliable book there is!
The Trinity
God is one and He is also three – the divine mystery that we are invited to enter, experience, and enjoy!
God The Father
The perfect reflection of what a Father should be and how He wants a personal, all satisfying relationship with you that no earthly parent can ever provide!
God The Son
God came down in human flesh to reflect and show how great, loving, and good the Father is!
God The Holy Spirit
God is always present to encourage, equip and empower us to serve Him by serving others!
Humanity
God’s greatest creation decided to live life their way but some have realized that life, the good life, is found only in Jesus Christ!
Salvation & The Gospel
God’s only way to connect with Him through a personal and public relationship with Him!
The Church
God’s design for community is to be the hands, feet, heart and mouth of Christ to a hurting and broken world. This is why the church is the hope of the world!
Common Questions
What Time Does Worship Begin?
Worship begins at 10:30 a.m. Service usually lasts around an hour.
Where Do I Park?
The church has a large parking lot. We have reserved guest spaces close to the front door. Feel free to park in one of those or any parking space you'd like.
What Is A Church Service Like?
You'll be greeted upon entry and will be directed into the sanctuary where you may sit anywhere you'd like. We begin the service with announcements, a few praise songs, an opening prayer. The children are dismissed to Sunday School and then Pastor Travis Mitchell will preach the sermon. After the sermon there is another song and a closing prayer. The first Sunday of every month is communion and any believer is welcome to join in.
After the service we welcome you to join us for fellowship in our cafe where we serve coffee and refreshments.
For a more detailed explanation, watch any of our services on Facebook or YouTube.
What Should I Wear?
Wear whatever you like. You'll see a few people dressed more formally but most are dressed casually (jeans). Wear what you are comfortable in.
How Do I Get to FBC?
We're located at 460 North Main in the historic village of Brewster, New York.
I Don’t Know Much About the Bible. Is That Okay?
Absolutely! Regardless of where you are on your spiritual journey, FBC is place for you to explore your faith. We are here to help you take that next step.
Do I Have To Stand Up In Front Of People?
No. You will receive a connection card that we ask you to complete so that we can keep you informed of upcoming events and activities. We'd appreciate you completing the information on the card and dropping it into one of the baskets at the back of the Sanctuary.
Will I Be Asked To Give Money?
Offering is not passed during our service. In the back of the church there are baskets if anyone would like to make a donation but it is not expected of guests.
Are You Going To Tell Me What's Wrong With Me?
At its core, the message of Jesus is good news. He did not come to earth to condemn us, but to save and lead us into the life we were made for. So you will find at FBC God’s Truth being expressed and at times it will comfort, encourage, and challenge you to think and live differently. And that’s a good thing as FBC is a place that desires to grow in loving God and people.
Where Do My Children Go?
We love kids! We have a dynamic children’s ministry called KID CITY. About 20-25 mins into the service children (5-12) are dismissed for children's church. Our KID CITY building is located 25 yards west of the church sanctuary. We also have a nursery available for families with infants. Please click "Plan A Visit" below so we can provide your child with the best possible experience.
Does FBC Have Any Expectations Of Me?
Yes we do. We expect you to . . . come as you are and not be perfect.
Who Can Tell Me More?
When you visit, we have greeters and a Welcome Center to answer your questions. The Welcome Center is conveniently located right inside the main entrance of the church. Also, for being our guest we would like to give you a welcome bag as a gift for checking us out. If you have any additional questions you can email us at info@brewsterchurch.com or calling us at 845-279-2636.
Please let us know you're planning to join us by clicking Plan A Visit below.
Copyright 2026 First Baptist Church Brewster
All Rights Reserved.